The torn one I removed had the same Johnson 812 part number on it.
Derek, yes our impellers are close; not to split hairs, it appears your vanes have more curl then mine, especially on the low pressure side... which may not matter.
Has anyone had to remove broken impeller pieces from the engine? And where did they accumulate? I've pulled the thermostat, both hoses to the water jackets, both hoses on the water pump, both heater hoses, and the lower oil cooler hose, and there's no sign of any pieces, or blockage.